The Optimal Model of Domestic Criminal Policy Against Ecocide (A Comparative Study of the Legal Systems of Iran, France, and Belgium)

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Afshin Abdollahi, Associate Prof, Law depart,ment, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Kurdistan, Sanandaj, Iran

2 PhD. in criminal law and criminology, at Paris-Nanterre University, France.

Abstract

The crime of ecocide, or severe harm and destruction to the environment, refers to a deliberate act that goes beyond ordinary fires and pollution. In the past two decades (since the year 2000) and given the international community's efforts and the extensive risks it poses, ecocide has entered the criminal policy of countries with progressive legal systems, including Belgium and France. However, the prespective of Iran's criminal justice system on this issue seems ambiguous. To prevent impunity and apply appropriate punishment for effective deterrence, the implementation of a suitable criminal policy appears essential. In this regard, the present research, using interpretative , has examined and analyzed the existing laws in the countries under study. It was found that both the Belgian and French legal systems, while criminalizing ecocide, distinguish it from unintentional pollution and environmental crimes. However, they differ in terms of the severity of the crime and the level of punishment. This research also highlights the gaps in Iran's legal system in this regard and, in conclusion, emphasizes the need to enact comprehensive legislation or amend existing laws to criminalize the crime of ecocide. It also underscores the preferred of the , particularly the severity of the crime committed.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

ABDOLLAHI, Afshin (2021), Criminal referral to Haad punishment in Ta’azirats, The Judiciarys Law journal, Volume 85, Issue 115, pp. 131-156. [In Persian]
BABAKHANI, Erfan (2023), On the effectiveness of restorative justice in the ecocide crime, Vilnius University Open Series, pp. 7–15.
BABAKHANI, Erfan (2022), Environmental Crimes in the Measure of Restorative Justice: from Policies to Programs, Journal of Legal Researche, Volume 22, Issue 53, pp. 443-468. [In Persian]
BARRAU, Aurélien (2020), Le plus grand défi de l’histoire de l’humanité, Face à la catastrophe écologique et sociale, Neuilly-sur-Seine, Michel Laffont.
BORN, Charles-Hubert, HERDT, Jeroen, ROZIE, Joëlle (2022), Vers l'insertion d'un crime d'écocide au titre de crime de droit international dans le nouveau Code pénal, Journal des tribunaux, pp. 297-307
BRISMAN, Avil, Nigel SOUTH. (2018) “Green Criminology and Environmental Crimes and Harms”. Sociology Compass 13(1), 1-12.
CASTIAUX, Gaëlle (2017), Revendication d’un crime d’écocide : les droits fondamentaux pour la protectionde l’environnement sont-ils suffisants ? Master mémoire, Université catholique de Louvain.
DELMAS-MARTY, M (2015), Préface de Neyret, Laurent (sous la dir.de), Des écocrimes à l’écocide. Le droit pénal au secours de l’environnement, Bruylant.
ENGONE ELLOUE, Nestor. (2018), Justice environnementale globale et responsabilité historique. Une approche restauratrice, Thèse, Université Bordeaux Montaigne
FRISSO, Giovanna Maria (2023), Ecocide: the environment as victim at the international criminal court, ICD Brif.
HAMILTON, Mark. (2021), Environmental Crime and Restorative Justice Justice as Meaningful Involvement, Palgrave Studies in Green Criminology.
HEIDARI, Aida, VAEZI, Mojtaba (2020), Criminal responsibility of government about Ecocide, Volume 2, Issue 3, pp. 37-67. [In Persian]
KOENNING-RUTHERFORD, Abbey (2023), Dishonoring the earth: ecocide as prosecutable genocide against indigenous people, the georgetown law journal.
MEHRA, Nassrin, GHOLIPOUR, Gholamreza, BABAKHANI, Erfan (2020), Ecocide: A Crime against Sustainable Development, in Ekonomik Suçlar, Ankara Üniversitesi.
MIRMOHAMMAD SADEQUI, Hossein (2023), Special Criminal Law (2): Crimes Against Public Interests, Mizan Publication, 45th Edition.
MOAZENZADEGAN, Hasanali, RAHDARPOUR, Hamed (2018), Transparency of Law Principle and its Position in the European Court of Human Rights Procedure and Iranian Criminal Law, Judicial Law Review, Volume 23, Issue 81, pp. 193-220. [In Persian]
MORIBE, Camila Misko et al (2023), Ecocide: a new crime challenge for the international crimiminal law and for humanity, journal of international criminal law.
NASR ESFAHANI, Ahmad, al. (2020), International Ecological Criminalization, Volume 17, Issue 19, pp. 273-304. [In Persian]
NEYRET, Laurent (2014), Pour la reconnaissence du crime d’écocide, Revue juridique de l’environnement.
NEYRET, Laurent (2016), From ecocrimes to ecocide: protection the environment through criminal law, Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha.
PEARCE, Fred (2014), When the Rivers Run Dry: Water, the Defining Crisis of the Twenty-first Century, translated by Beheshtid Delili, Tehran, Bahjat Publications, First Edition. [In Persian]
ROZBEH, Mehrdad, al. (2024), Ecocide in the Light of Criminal Law with the Formation of Criminal Behaviors in Environmental Degradation, Volume 22, Issue 56, pp. 493-532. [In Persian]
SHAMLO, Bagher, GOULIPOUR, Gholamreza (2020), Ecocide: A Crime against Sustainable Development, Criminal Law and Criminology Studies, Volume 50, Issue 1, pp. 137-162. [In Persian]
SHAMLO, Bagher, GOULIPOUR, Gholamreza (2022), Galston's Legal Legacy: re-reading the Birth Process of the Concept of Ecocide, Criminal law research, Volume 13, Issue 1, pp. 225-254. [In Persian]
ZIERLER, David (2011), The Invention of Ecocide: Agent Orange, Vietnam, and the Scientists Who Changed the Way We Think about the Environment, Athens, University of Georgia Press.

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics